THANK YOU youroo! THANK YOU Bama Rambler! THANK YOU ellioml! The switch was wired incorrectly. Only had the 20 amp circuit breaker left to try it after making the changes, but it is working both directions. Will pick up some 20 amp fuses and check it again.
Always use the old saying "when the drinkin' starts, the workin' stops." Must have been somewhere in the middle when I did this job. LOL