IMO trailer tires with high usage as Original Equipment tires are never going to have better reviews than tires not used as OE tires but heavily used as replacements for OE tires.
Marathon, Carlisle, Towmax, Mission and Uniroyal have all been highly used as OE Tires. Maxxis has not.
Don't get me wrong there, Maxxis is just as good as the others but is often used a load range above the OE tires they replaced. That makes their reviews a little lopsided.
Maxxis does not have the highly regarded nylon overlay on all of their 8008 sizes whereas Marathon, Carlisle and Towmax do have the nylon overlay on all of their premium tires.
USN - RET - PDRL
DOD - RET - Journeyman Aircraft Mechanic
SSA - RET