+1 on using something that isn't good nesting material for critters. Also, where there is access to the outside, consider layers of hardware cloth or rustproof steel wool with the foam. Or Exacto blades.
They love fiberglass insulation for nesting material, and they'll eat thru plain foam.
Foam is a good insulator, but Reflectix is actually not. The Reflectix is awesome stuff, but they ain't telling the truth about its R value.