I've got a Roo 23ss and am in need of a portable tank.
It looks like the two brands of choice include the Barker Tote Along and the other manufacturer making the Tote n Stor.
I'm comparing the 22 gal Tote Along, 15 gal Tote Along with the 25 gal Tote N Stor and 15 gal Tote n Stor - all two wheel models.
For those that utilize the portable tanks, why did you select the brand purchased? Any issues with transferring the grey water to the portable tank? I've read comments from a purchaser that the high profile of the tote n store that some guy purchased was a few inches higher than his tank outlet. Seems to me that the force of the grey water wouldn't present an issue. Thoughts?
My grey water tank is 30 gal, but I'm not opposed to making a couple of trips if required. At the very least I'm looking to avoid having to hook up the Roo to dump the grey.
It seems like the tote n Stor offers a storage compartment for the gear needed, yet the tote along is a bit more expensive. What gives?
If it is just grey water, I use a 5 gallon bucket. Two trips each night I get rid of 8 gallons. At the end of the week the grey water tank is full & I can do a proper dump on the way out of the campground. This is not a good idea for the black water .
I would look at the smaller size just for ease of handling. Your DW might have to do this job sometime too, so size matters. I have seen some campers pull large tanks with their TV.
__________________
2021 Rockwood Mini Lite 2109S
2010 Toyota Tundra 4WD
We used a Barker when we had our popup and hybrid. Get one that you can tow slowely behind your F150. It makes the job alot easier in campgrounds with gravel roads or if the dump station is far from your site.
I've got a Roo 23ss and am in need of a portable tank.
It looks like the two brands of choice include the Barker Tote Along and the other manufacturer making the Tote n Stor.
I'm comparing the 22 gal Tote Along, 15 gal Tote Along with the 25 gal Tote N Stor and 15 gal Tote n Stor - all two wheel models.
For those that utilize the portable tanks, why did you select the brand purchased?
You missed one big brand - Thetford Smart Tote.
I chose the Thetford product since I think that it is built better than the Barker - the other top choice. I got the 35 gallon tank since its capacity is larger than any of my tanks, and it works very well. You want to get one with 4 wheels, and the larger the wheels the better. Water is very heavy so you need to bear in mind that you will need to manually move the tank from the side of the RV to the truck.
Sorry I don't want to change the thread here, but I was thinking of using a flojet macerator to pump it into a Portable tote as well! I don't have either yet! Instead of pulling the tote it would sit in the pickup bed and drive to the dump station. It would also solve the problem of RV drain being lower than top of tote. And how well do the flojet pumps work???
__________________
Of all the things I've lost in my life the thing I miss the most is my mind!
I have a Barker Tank - 32gl IIRC. The Barker is very well thought of amongst the RVing population. You can search here, RV.net and other places for details but my internet search several years ago pointed me to the Barker as the best of the bunch. Re: Wayne's Thetford - they might be as good or better. Thetford has a good name.
Remember that water weighs 8.35lbs per gl. So, filling up that 15gl tote makes it 125lbs with the weight of the tote (~10lbs). The recommendation to get one with sturdy wheels is a good one. You really don't want to try to man-handle one of these and you don't want it flipping.
I chose mine because it has four wheels and can be hitched to my truck. I've never filled it up completely, but its supposed to weigh 270lbs full. The smallest four-wheel job from Barker is their 16-gl and that weighs 135lbs full. Both of those weights are too much for me to lift so I figured I might as well go with the larger one.
But, I might do it differently now and get a smaller one. The 32gl tank is big and bulky and the Roos don't have a lot of storage for this size. Just some food for thought.
__________________
Scott
DW, 3 Kids and our Goldens
2012 Shamrock 233S
2008 Toyota Sequoia 5.7L 4WD
I don't have one, yet. I've thought about it for pumping to my home septic but haven't pulled the trigger. I have see them at work and am impressed. Its been discussed a lot so here's some FRF search results in case you don't get anything else.
I had one of the blue totes before but bought the Thetford (27 gal) this time. It seems to be well built, but there are a few stupid things wrong with mine.
1) The printed instructions for removing the vent assembly tell you to turn it the wrong way. They've corrected it on-line and I assume they'll sell out of the "wrong" ones after a while.
2) The screws that attach the handle to the tank are too short to reach the nylon in the nylon lock nuts. I lost one first time out and replaced it (and the others) with 1-1/4 stainless.
3) The four washers on the main axle are all behind the wheels. I'm quite sure that one should be on the outside of each wheel, behind the press-on nut.
Still, I'd buy it again. The front swivel wheel is heavy-duty and I like the way it attaches to a hitch ball.
Sorry I don't want to change the thread here, but I was thinking of using a flojet macerator to pump it into a Portable tote as well! I don't have either yet! Instead of pulling the tote it would sit in the pickup bed and drive to the dump station. It would also solve the problem of RV drain being lower than top of tote. And how well do the flojet pumps work???
I think this is the best answer (even for the OP). There's no manhandling a heavy tote and no driving extra-extra slow through the campground.
Now, if my family wasn't a bunch of Wookies- I'd consider one. For now, I only camp with full hookups.
__________________
Officially a SOB with a 2022 Jayco Precept 36C
Checkout my site for RVing tips, tricks, and info | Was a Fulltime Family for 5 years, now we're part-timing on long trips
I also have a barker 32 gallon 4 wheel and love it! I had a barker 25 gal 4 wheel and also loved it I wanted more capacity but 42 was to tall. All my friends laught when I bought it now they all use it. Trust me get a 4 wheel either way you go they get very heavy. Call barker direct they sold me the tank and electric tongue jack direct.
not sure what Wmoses is getting his info from, but the most recommended and loved Tote Tank is the blue Barker, by far.
on every RV forum i belong to, the Barker gets the most recommendations.
the Thetford is a distant second.
__________________
Dan-Retired California Firefighter/EMT
Shawn-Musician/Entrepreneur/Wine Expert
and Zoe the Wonder Dog(R.I.P.)
2016 PrimeTime TracerAIR 255, pushing a 2014 Ford F150 SCREW XTR 4x4 3.5 Ecoboost w/Max Tow Package
4pt Equal-i-zer WDH and 1828lbs of payload capacity
I like mine... specially after the rubber tires mod.
That 42 gallon tank is heavy when full and being able to dump it without lifting it is a real plus. Since my holding tanks are 40 gallons each, I can completely dump my tanks.
__________________
Lou & Freya the wonder dog
2008 GMC Sierra 3000HD Allison Duramax
2019 Flagstaff 8529FL
X2 on the Barker as the best. When researching what owners of both totes had to say, Barker won out.
__________________
2006 Rockwood 8272S
2005 Chevrolet Silverado
John & Pandra
Battlefield, Missouri
F.R.O.G. Member
1st International F.R.O.G. Rally Branson Missouri
not sure what Wmoses is getting his info from, but the most recommended and loved Tote Tank is the blue Barker, by far.
on every RV forum i belong to, the Barker gets the most recommendations.
the Thetford is a distant second.
Dan - I never said my Thetford was "best", did I? I said I preferred it. It works great for me - built well, works well, tough durable AND it looks better than the Barkers. That is my opinion.
BTW - not because most of the people who post on forums like a certain thing we should conclude that it is the best. The best that one can conclude is that it is the most popular among the set of people on that particular forum. To conclude otherwise would be simple enumeration.
I chose the Thetford product since I think that it is built better than the Barker - the other top choice.
i didn't say that you said "best". but you did say it was built better.
we can agree to disagree, i was just surprised to see a post promoting the Thetford over the Barker.
i've read hundreds of posts on RV.net comparing the two and only a couple liked the Thetford over the Barker. most that had Thetford, ended up hating it.
but, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and so are tote tanks!
glad you're happy with yours.
__________________
Dan-Retired California Firefighter/EMT
Shawn-Musician/Entrepreneur/Wine Expert
and Zoe the Wonder Dog(R.I.P.)
2016 PrimeTime TracerAIR 255, pushing a 2014 Ford F150 SCREW XTR 4x4 3.5 Ecoboost w/Max Tow Package
4pt Equal-i-zer WDH and 1828lbs of payload capacity
My procrastination once again presented itself. I finally purchased a tote to be delivered tomorrow - just in time for our 4 day camping adventure this weekend.
I went with the newer 4 wheel model tote n stor (25 gal). I like the storage cubby for the necessary gear as well as the components that come with the tank.
Looking forward to utilizing the tote as my hunch is we will need to shower a bit more as the summer temps here in Texas have arrived. Expected to reach 98 on Sunday
My procrastination once again presented itself. I finally purchased a tote to be delivered tomorrow - just in time for our 4 day camping adventure this weekend.
I went with the newer 4 wheel model tote n stor (25 gal). I like the storage cubby for the necessary gear as well as the components that come with the tank.
Looking forward to utilizing the tote as my hunch is we will need to shower a bit more as the summer temps here in Texas have arrived. Expected to reach 98 on Sunday
I had the 22 gal. Barker- regardless of how many wheels, they get heavy quick. Figure 8.3 lbs/gal don't fill too much or you'll regret when time to lift for empty. More trips is better.