Jim, I turned off the daily newsletter to you. If you will, now go to the full site and click on the "community" tab on the top toolbar. Click on the "newletter" option and enter the email address you wish to have it sent to. Follow all the prompts.
Go to your "user cp" in the toolbar and then "edit options" scroll down to near bottom and make sure turn on the daily newsletter and save changes.
See if that solves it.
This thread may also help with screenshots:
The daily newsletter is a separate function from your profile email. You can have different email accounts for it. You also can even subscribe to the daily newsletter without being a registered member of the forums. It's administered by a third party.
You unsubscribe from the daily newsletter from a link within the newsletter (which you may have to do with your old account)