Quote:
Originally Posted by cobaltpap
Just remember that if one of your 6 volt batteries goes bad you will have no power at all. If one of the 12 volt batteries goes bad then you can still run everything on the other
12 volt battery.
|
One of the enduring fallacies in the RV world. Unless you keep the 12V batteries isolated from each other (or have individual battery monitoring systems), one "going bad" will quickly drain the other.
The greater the disparity in voltage between the 2 batteries, the faster the "good" battery will be drained - we're talking minutes here, with wire melting currents for a shorted cell in one battery. I have the T-shirt.
Fortunately, this rarely happens. In the more typical case, where one of the two batteries won't hold much of a charge, the "bad" battery becomes the limiting factor on total battery capacity. As the voltage in the bad battery sags under load, the good battery pumps charge into the bad battery to maintain the same voltage that a parallel circuit requires. That charge pumped into the bad battery is not available for other loads. How will you detect that one of the batteries is going bad? And you still have to replace them in pairs, unlike 6V.
Unless you are constantly on top of what's going on with your batteries, the series 6V battery solution is generally the more robust solution. But either dual battery solution works well
as long as both batteries are in good condition.
I switched to 6V (from dual 12V) because I believe in KISS. I can tell from system voltage an approximate state of charge, and how the battery pair is doing. Or if connected to shore power, system voltage tells me what the converter is doing.
Fred W
2019 Flagstaff T21TBHW A-frame with dual 6V Costco-Interstate batteries, Progressive Dynamics converter, no generator, no solar
2008 Hyundai Entourage minivan
camping Colorado and adjacent states one weekend at a time