Quote:
Originally Posted by bikendan
By the way, there is no such thing as a HD tv antenna. It's a marketing scam.
You could plug a rabbit ears antenna with tinfoil wrapped around it and get a HD tv signal.
It's the tv that has to be HD, NOT the antenna.
|
True to a point. If you are close to the transmitter a coat hanger might work too.
Issue with antenna's shows up both when you switch the UHF stations. Original TV was on VHF (54-216 mhz)and less than 10% of the stations today are on VHF. UHF can range from 470-890 mhz.
The issue with antennas is that they need to be designed to receive channels in several different frequency wave lengths. Long elements for VHF, short elements for UHF. Furthermore, in each band there are different element lengths that match the different wavelengths for he different frequencies within the band. Look at a rooftop antenna and notice the number horizontal elements that range from a couple feet across to down to a few inches. Each length "resonates" with the different frequencies and does a better job of receiving a specific channel.
Analog signals were easier to pick up and you usually got some type of a signal although maybe a little fuzzy. Digital is either there or it's not. Antenna's need to be more precise in design in order to receive the entire spectrum with enough signal strength to keep the picture from looking like a bad LSD trip from the 60's. Since HD is broadcast in digital format it requires a good signal to keep the picture going. When in the fringe areas antenna's become more important, especially ones that are tuned to receive ALL channels well.
Since most people don't understand HOW the signal is transmitted or what effect different frequencies have on antenna design the industry has just simplified things. They call antennas that receive the large number of UHF channels as well as the original VHF channels "HD Antennas".
If you live more than about 20 miles from a TV tower chances are Rabbit Ears are not going to cut it unless you are on a mountain top and can see the tower on a clear day with binoculars..
PS: one of my several lifetime achievements was the acquisition of a FCC 2nd Class Radiotelephone Operator's license as well as having an Uncle that was lead engineer for one of Seattle's main TV Stations. Obtaining the license was a college class requirement while doing some Electronic's course work.
__________________
"A wise man can change his mind. A fool never will." (Japanese Proverb)
"You only grow old when you run out of new things to do"
2018 Flagstaff Micro Lite 25BDS
2023 f-150 SCREW XLT 3.5 Ecoboost (The result of a $68,000 oil change
)